I love shaggy mane mushrooms. A lot of foragers love shaggy mane mushrooms, but they generally don't love them when and how I love them.
When young and fresh and pure white, shaggy mane mushrooms are mild and mellow in flavor. While mellow, the flavor they have is softly sweet, creamy, a bit nutty and there's another, ephemeral flavor that's otherwise hard to place. They also don't have a meaty texture, they are rather soft and stringy.
![]() |
| Fresh young shaggy mane mushrooms |
The most common critique of this mushroom is that, since it deliquesces quickly after maturing and/or being picked, it can be difficult to work with. And I 100% understand with that critique. If you're not familiar with deliquescence, it's the process by which the mushroom turns to goo to release its spores. And while that's both very cool and the mycelium (the actual organism that grows the mushroom), it means the forager has a very limited window to 1) pick the mushroom, 2) get the mushroom home, 3) cook the mushroom, before it turns into black goo.
To complicate things further, refrigerating these mushrooms doesn't slow the process down much. The only way to stop these mushrooms from dissolving is to either cook them or freeze them. Which is generally fine when you find while intentionally foraging, but is a real pain when you find them accidentally. And I find a LOT accidentally.
While I have a couple of spots I can rely on to provide me a good number of mushrooms most every year (including my front lawn), they also pop up when I'm not actively looking for them, in places like 1) my job, 2) one of the many the trails I walk at lunch sometimes, 3) local parks, 4) various greenspaces around town, 5) the lawns of my neighbors. And when I find these mushrooms, I just can't help myself, I have to pick them as long as I can reasonably determine that they haven't been sprayed with something. Which is a problem, because I generally am not set up to cook while at work or walking a trail on lunch break, or running errands. And I can't refrigerate them, because they will deliquesce. So, I end up tossing them in a container and then putting them in the freezer. I bring them home and add them to a bigger bag in the freezer.But then, what do with the frozen shaggy manes? I can't defrost them because they will, once again, turn to goo. Without defrosting, I can't make popular dishes like breaded and fried shaggy manes. And slowly but surely, that bag in my freezer gets fuller and fuller. I had to make a recipe that cooked the mushrooms at the same time as they defrosted. My first thought was a soup or a stew, but with Thanksgiving right around the corner, my husband suggested stuffing.
Because here's the thing about deliquescence--it totally changes the shaggy mane's flavor! And that's why I say that I like shaggy manes when MOST foragers DON'T like them: I like them even when they turn to goo! You see, as they deliquesce they become a lot more mushroomy. The flavor goes from smooth and mellow to in-your-face and intense. So if you like a strong mushroom flavor, give deliquescing shaggy manes a shot!
![]() |
| This recipe uses the mushroom's natural deliquescence as a flavor-enhancer. |
For this recipe, I used my standard turkey stock to make this stuffing (recipe below), but you could use vegetable stock or bullion instead, for a vegetarian option.
Cheesy shaggy mane mushroom stuffing
Serves 6-9 as a side
- 3/4 loaf of Italian bread, cut into approximately 3/4in cubes
- 1 quart-sized bag of frozen shaggy mane mushrooms
- 8 oz shredded havarti or other soft, smooth, mild, melty cheese
- 1 jumbo white onion, diced
- 2-3 stalks of celery, cut into 1/3in wide slices
- 5 cloves of garlic, minced
- 3 cups of turkey, chicken or vegetarian stock or broth
- 1/2 cup whole milk
- 1/2 cup heavy cream
- cooked minced turkey organ meat, optional
- olive oil
- butter
- salt & pepper
- Preheat your oven to the broil setting. Drizzle a small amount of olive oil on a baking pan and lightly spread it with a piece of Italian bread. Spread the cubed bread over the baking pan. Broil for 2-3 minutes, watching that they toast but don't burn. Remove from the oven, allow to cool and add to a large mixing bowl.
- Turn your oven to bake and set to 350 degrees.
- Heat olive oil and a pat of butter in a large 5qt. sauté pan over medium heat. Add in the diced white onion and the minced garlic. Sauté, stirring constantly, until onion translucent and soft. Remove the aromatics from the pan and add them to the mixing bowl with the toasted bread.
- Add more oil and butter to the sauté pan and reduce heat to low. Add your mushrooms, still frozen, to the sauté pan.
- Heat the mushrooms through over medium-high heat, allowing the mushrooms to defrost while cooking. They will deliquesce. As they defrost slowly break them apart in the pan and season lightly with salt and pepper. Let them continue to cook, absorbing the liquid that comes off them, until that liquid is reduced by half.
- As the mushrooms become fully cooked, break them apart into bite-sized pieces or smaller. Remove the mushrooms from the pan and mix them and any remaining mushroom liquid in with the bread, onions and garlic. Mix in the celery and 2/3 of the shredded cheese. If you're using cooked organ meat, mix it in as well. Do not use raw meat.
- Coat the bottom of a 13x9 casserole dish with butter or olive oil. Spread the stuffing mix out over the dish.
- Pour the stock evenly over the stuffing and sprinkle the remaining 1/3 cheese over the top.
- Bake in the 350 oven for 50 minutes to 1 hour, or until an inserted butter knife comes out clean.
Turkey organ stock
- turkey organs: heart, neck, liver, gizzards and tail
- 8 cups of water
- 3 cloves of garlic, sliced
- 1 small yellow onion, cut into chunks
- 2 bay leaves
- 1 tbs. salt
- 1 tbs. freshly ground black pepper
- dried tarragon and basil to taste
- olive oil and/or butter
- Brown the organ meat in olive oil in a large stockpot over medium-high heat. When browned, but not cooked through, remove the meat from the pan and add more oil or butter, if needed.
- Add the onion and garlic to the pan and sauté until translucent. Increase the heat to high and lightly brown everything.
- Pour the water into the stockpot over the vegetables. Add the meat back in along with the bay leaves, salt, pepper and dried herbs.
- Simmer for 2-3 hours, skimming the foam as needed. Strain out solids.












